When it comes to choosing the best deck railing for your outdoor space, aluminum and composite are two of the most popular options. Both have their advantages, but there are important differences to consider in terms of performance, aesthetics, and long-term durability. In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both materials to help you make an informed decision.
Early Issues with Composite Deck Railing
Composite deck railing was developed as a low-maintenance alternative to wood. However, in its early stages, some composite railing faced several significant problems:
- Staining: Some composite railing was prone to absorbing dirt, making it difficult to keep clean and prone to discoloration.
- Mold Growth: The combination of wood fibers and plastic provided a breeding ground for mold, especially in damp environments.
- Delamination: Exposure to moisture could cause early composite railings to delaminate, where the layers separate, leading to structural issues.
- Cracking and Peeling: The plastic finish on composite railings often cracked or peeled, especially when exposed to temperature fluctuations or harsh sunlight.
While these issues have been addressed over time, they still serve as a reminder of the challenges associated with earlier composite railing systems. Some homeowners and contractors that experienced these issues still lack trust in composite railing. However as stated the newer improved versions show they perform much better without those issues.
Modern Composite Deck Railing: Bulkier, But Improved
The latest versions of composite railing have seen significant improvements, with manufacturers addressing many of the problems that plagued early designs. Today, composite railings are:
- More Durable: They are now better at resisting mold, staining, and delamination, thanks to enhanced technology and manufacturing processes.
- Low-Maintenance: Like aluminum, composite railings don’t require painting, staining, or sealing. A simple wash with soap and water can keep them looking good.
However, one characteristic that remains is their bulkier design. Composite railings tend to have a thicker profile, which can work well for certain home designs, especially those that favor a more substantial, traditional look. But this bulk can also obstruct views and feel a bit overpowering in some settings.
Aluminum Deck Railing: Sleek, Strong, and Dependable
Aluminum deck railing, by contrast, is known for its slimmer profile, which offers both aesthetic and practical benefits:
- Unobstructed Views: The sleek design of aluminum railings provides a cleaner, more open appearance, making them ideal for decks with scenic views or homeowners who prefer a minimalist look.
- Durability: Aluminum railings are highly resistant to rust, corrosion, and weather damage. They stand up to the elements—rain, snow, sun, or saltwater—with little to no wear.
- Strength Without the Bulk: Despite their lightweight and slim design, aluminum railings are incredibly strong and can withstand heavy use without sagging or warping.
Which is Better for Your Home?
Ultimately, the choice between aluminum and composite railing depends on your specific needs and design preferences.
- Composite railing offers a more substantial look that can complement traditional homes or those with a heavier architectural style. Modern versions of composite perform well and require little maintenance, but they tend to be bulkier and may obstruct views.
- Aluminum railing, on the other hand, is perfect for homeowners seeking a sleek, modern look with long-lasting performance. Its slim profile provides strength without the bulk, offering less obstructed views and a more open feel. Many homeowners have found that aluminum railings are tried and true, performing consistently well for many years with minimal maintenance.
Conclusion
If you’re drawn to a classic, heavier look, composite railing might be the right choice for your deck. However, if you prefer a more contemporary aesthetic with clean lines and less obstruction, aluminum deck railing stands out as a superior option. Its durability, ease of maintenance, and sleek profile make it a favorite among homeowners looking for a reliable, long-term solution.
When choosing between the two, consider the overall style of your home, your desired level of maintenance, and how important an open view is to you. Either way, both materials offer excellent alternatives to traditional wood, with aluminum leading the way in strength and unobstructed design.