When it comes to building a deck, the type of wood you choose can make all the difference in terms of durability, aesthetics, and maintenance. Among the many options available, cedar decking stands out as a popular choice for homeowners. But how does it stack up against other wood options like pressure-treated lumber and exotic hardwoods? Let’s break it down.
Cedar Decking vs. Pressure-Treated Wood
Cedar decking has long been prized for its natural beauty, rich grain, and warm tones that add a timeless appeal to any outdoor space. One of its standout features is its durability when properly maintained. With regular sealing, staining, and cleaning, cedar decking has proven to last 25 years or more. This longevity stems from cedar’s natural resistance to rot, insects, and weathering, thanks to the oils and tannins present in the wood.
In contrast, pressure-treated wood—typically pine infused with chemicals to resist decay—has been a go-to budget-friendly option for decades. However, the newer formulations of pressure-treated lumber have left some homeowners disappointed. While older versions were treated with harsher chemicals like chromated copper arsenate (CCA), modern pressure-treated wood uses less toxic alternatives.
Unfortunately, this shift has come at a cost: we’ve seen reports of rotting in as little as 10 to 15 years, even with maintenance. This shorter lifespan, combined with its less appealing yellowish-green hue (which often requires staining to mask), makes it a less durable and visually appealing option compared to cedar.
Cedar does come with a slightly higher upfront cost than pressure-treated wood, but its longevity and lower long-term replacement costs often make it a worthwhile investment. Plus, cedar’s natural aroma and resistance to warping give it an edge for those seeking a premium decking experience.
Exploring Hardwood Alternatives
Beyond cedar and pressure-treated lumber, exotic hardwoods offer another tier of decking options. Species like Ipe, Cumaru, Tigerwood, Garapa, Teak, Brazilian Redwood, and Mahogany bring unmatched strength and beauty to the table. Here’s how they compare:
Ipe
Benefits: Known for its extreme durability and resistance to weather, insects, and wear, Ipe is one of the hardest woods available. Its deep reddish-brown color is stunning.
Lifespan: 50+ years with proper care.
Price: High—often $5 – $7 per linear foot or more, making it one of the priciest options.
Cumaru
Benefits: Similar to Ipe in hardness and durability, Cumaru offers a rich, reddish-brown tone at a slightly lower cost.
Lifespan: 40–50 years.
Price: $4–$5 per linear foot.
Tigerwood
Benefits: Its striking tiger-like stripes make it a showstopper. It’s also highly durable and resistant to moisture.
Lifespan: 30–40 years.
Price: $2–$3 per linear foot.
Garapa
Benefits: A lighter golden-brown hardwood, Garapa resists rot and weathering while offering a smoother finish than some other hardwoods.
Lifespan: 30–40 years.
Price: $2–$3 per linear foot.
Teak
Benefits: Famous for its use in marine applications, teak is naturally water-resistant and has a luxurious golden hue that grays beautifully over time.
Lifespan: 20-30 years.
Price: $3–$4 per linear foot.
Brazilian Redwood
Benefits: With a deep red color and exceptional hardness, this wood resists scratches and weathering effectively.
Lifespan: 40–50 years.
Price: $3–$4 per linear foot.
Mahogany
Benefits: Offers a classic, rich reddish-brown look with good resistance to rot and insects. It’s slightly softer than other hardwoods but still robust.
Lifespan: 30–40 years.
Price: $3–$4 per linear foot.
Why Choose Cedar?
While exotic hardwoods boast incredible lifespans and jaw-dropping aesthetics, the higher end species like Ipe and Cumaru are more expensive. Cedar strikes a balance: it’s more affordable than some hardwoods (typically $2–$3 per linear foot), easier to work with, and still delivers a long-lasting, attractive deck with proper care. Unlike pressure-treated wood, which may falter in a decade or so, cedar’s proven 25+ year lifespan makes it a reliable middle-ground option.
Additionally many homes have numerous cedar elements such as siding, trim etc… so if you are matching existing cedar then choosing cedar is a wise choice.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right decking material depends on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and willingness to maintain it. Cedar decking offers a compelling mix of durability, natural beauty, and value, outlasting newer pressure-treated lumber by a wide margin. For those seeking the ultimate in longevity and luxury, exotic hardwoods like Ipe or Teak are hard to beat—though your wallet will feel the difference. Weigh your priorities, and you’ll find the perfect wood to bring your outdoor vision to life.